THIS IS A NON LIVE LOCATION
Skip to main
Papa J's Pizza Bar & Grill
  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Chicken Wings
  • Chicken Fingers
  • Pizza
  • Pizza by the Slice
  • Cold Subs
  • Hot Subs
  • Hoagie Subs
  • Monday Pizza Frenzy
  • Specials
  • Taco Tuesday Special Pick Up Only
  • Wing Wednesday Pick Up Only Specials
  • Specialty Pizza
  • Salads
  • Tacos
  • Sandwiches
  • Fish Fry Every Day
  • Desserts
  • Seafood

Papa J's Pizza Bar & Grill Menu

395 Shanley St, Buffalo, NY

395 Shanley St, Buffalo, NY

·

  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Chicken Wings
  • Chicken Fingers
  • Pizza
  • Pizza by the Slice
  • Cold Subs
  • Hot Subs
  • Hoagie Subs
  • Monday Pizza Frenzy
  • Specials
  • Taco Tuesday Special Pick Up Only
  • Wing Wednesday Pick Up Only Specials
  • Specialty Pizza
  • Salads
  • Tacos
  • Sandwiches
  • Fish Fry Every Day
  • Desserts
  • Seafood

Popular

  • Steak Hoagie.

    Steak Hoagie

    $14.99+

  • Meat Lovers Pizza.

    Meat Lovers Pizza

    $13.99+

  • Chicken Wings.

    Chicken Wings

    $14.99+

  • Cheese Pizza.

    Cheese Pizza

    $11.99+

  • Chicken Finger Sub.

    Chicken Finger Sub

    $8.99+

Appetizers

Pizza Logs

$9.99

5 pieces, comes with marinara sauce.

Fried Cauliflower

$8.99

Comes with ranch.

Jalapeño Poppers

$7.99

5 pieces, comes with ranch.

Taco in a Box

$16.99

Comes with Doritos, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce.

Mozzarella Sticks

$7.99

5 pieces, comes with marinara sauce.

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$9.99

Comes with marinara sauce.

Fried Mushrooms

$8.99

Comes with ranch.

Eggroll Flight

$17.99

1 each: chicken, steak, and seafood. Comes with hoagie sauce and seafood sauce.

Tater Tots

$4.99

Comes with ketchup.

Tater Tots.

Eggrolls

$16.99

Comes with hoagie sauce, parmesan and parsley.

Fries

$4.99

Large. Comes with ketchup.

Loaded Fries

$14.99+

Comes with cheese, sour cream, and chipotle ranch.

Onion Rings

$5.49

Large. Comes with ketchup.

Steak Hoagie Fries

$15.99

A pile of fries loaded with chopped steak hoagie meat, melted cheese, and hoagie toppings.

Big Boy Box

$19.99

3 Pizza Logs, 3 Jalapeño Poppers, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 fingers, fries, 1 Beef taco. Comes with ketchup, ranch, two marinara sauces, and taco lettuce, tomato, cheese, taco sauce.

Loaded Tots

$14.99+

Comes with cheese, sour cream, and chipotle ranch.

Cajun Fries

$5.99

Comes with ketchup.

Chicken Hoagie Fries

$14.99

Comes with onions, banana peppers, cheese, and hoagie sauce.

Chicken Wings

Chicken Wings

$14.99+

Served with celery & blue cheese.

Chicken Wings.

Chicken Wings from the Pit

$16.99+

Served with celery and blue cheese.

Chicken Wings from the Pit.

Country Style Fried Chicken Wings

$16.99

10 pieces served with celery and blue cheese. Available in lemon pepper, Cajun, and Honey Cajun.

Country Style Fried Chicken Wings.

Chicken Fingers

Chicken Finger Dinner

$14.99+

Comes with 4-6 chicken fingers. Served with celery, blue cheese, and a side of fries.

Pizza

Cheese Pizza

$11.99+

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

Cheese Pizza.

Pizza by the Slice

Pepperoni Pizza Slice

$3.99

Pepperoni Pizza Slice.

Cheese Pizza Slice

$3.49

Cold Subs

All subs come with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomato, cheese & a toasted roll.

Ham Sub

$8.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Turkey Sub

$8.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Salami Sub

$8.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Capicola Sub

$8.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

BLT Sub

$8.99+

Comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Cheese Sub

$7.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Assorted Sub

$8.99+

Comes with ham, turkey, salami, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Roast Beef Sub

$8.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Tuna Sub

$7.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Turkey Club Sub

$8.99+

Comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions.

Hot Subs

Chicken Finger Sub

$8.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and cheese.

Chicken Finger Sub.

Stinger Sub

$9.99+

Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.

Steak Sub

$9.90+

Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.

Steak Sub.

Royal Sub

$8.99+

Italian sausage and capicola. Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.

Meatball Bomber Sub

$8.99+

Comes with pizza sauce and cheese.

Pizza Sub

$8.99+

Comes with mozzarella, pizza sauce, and pepperoni.

Cheeseburger Sub

$8.99+

Comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, ketchup, and mustard.

Cheeseburger Sub.

Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

$9.49+

Comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cheese, ketchup, and mustard.

Bacon Cheeseburger Sub.

Italian Sausage Sub

$8.99+

Chicken Parmesan Sub

$8.99+

Comes with pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Hoagie Subs

Chop Chicken Hoagie

$13.99+

Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, sub cheese, and our homemade steak sauce.

Chop Turkey Hoagie

$11.99+

Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, lettuce, sub cheese, and our homemade steak sauce.

Chop Burger Hoagie

$12.99+

Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, sub cheese, ketchup, mustard, and our homemade steak sauce.

Steak Hoagie

$14.99+

Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, sub cheese, and our homemade steak sauce.

Steak Hoagie.

Monday Pizza Frenzy

Mon

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

Cheese Pizza

$8.24+

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

White Pizza

$10.49+

White Pizza.

Taco Pizza

$10.49+

Hawaiian Pizza

$10.49+

Chicken Finger Pizza

$10.49+

Chicken Finger Pizza.

Steak Pizza

$10.49+

Breakfast Pizza

$10.49+

Veggie Pizza

$9.74+

Vegan cheese optional.

Meat Lovers Pizza

$10.49+

Pepperoni, sausage, and ham.

Meat Lovers Pizza.

Chicken & Broccoli Pizza

$10.49+

Chicken & Broccoli Pizza.

Stinger Pizza

$10.49+

Chicken fingers, steak, cheddar cheese, and hot sauce.

Stinger Pizza.

Specials

Small Cheese Pizza & Single Wings

$28.99

1 Slice, 3 Chicken Fingers & 1 Egg Roll

$13.99

Comes with a slice of cheese and pepperoni pizza, a chicken egg roll, and 3 chicken fingers.

Large Cheese Pizza & Bucket of Wings

$48.99+

Large cheese pizza and double wings (20 pieces) or bucket of wings (50 pieces).

Cold Sub of the Month

$9.99

Ask about our sub of the Month!

Hot Sub of the Month

$10.99

Ask about our sub of the Month!

Sheet Cheese Pizza & Bucket of Wings

$86.99

Sheet cheese pizza and bucket of wings (50 pieces).

Taco Tuesday Special Pick Up Only

Tue

Only available Tuesday. Pick up only.

Beef Taco Special

$3.00

Comes with fresh tomatoes, shredded lettuce, and cheese.

Chicken Taco Special

$3.00

Comes with fresh tomatoes, shredded lettuce, and cheese.

Wing Wednesday Pick Up Only Specials

Wed

Only available Wednesday for pickup.

Wings Special

$10.00+

Served with celery and blue cheese. Limit is 2 orders or up to 20 wings. Not available for delivery.

Wings Special.

Specialty Pizza

White Pizza

$13.99+

White Pizza.

Veggie Pizza

$12.99+

Vegan cheese optional.

Taco Pizza

$13.99+

Meat Lovers Pizza

$13.99+

Pepperoni, sausage, and ham.

Meat Lovers Pizza.

Hawaiian Pizza

$13.99+

Chicken & Broccoli Pizza

$13.99+

Chicken & Broccoli Pizza.

Chicken Finger Pizza

$13.99+

Chicken Finger Pizza.

Stinger Pizza

$13.99+

Chicken fingers, steak, cheddar cheese, and hot sauce.

Stinger Pizza.

Steak Pizza

$13.99+

Steak Hoagie Pizza

$13.99+

Topped with steak, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and our homemade hoagie sauce.

Steak Hoagie Pizza.

Breakfast Pizza

$13.99+

Chicken Hoagie Pizza

$13.99+

Topped with chicken, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and our homemade hoagie sauce.

Pepperoni Pizza Slice

$3.99

Pepperoni Pizza Slice.

Cheese Pizza Slice

$3.49

Salads

Tacos: come with lettuce, tomato, taco sauce, and cheese on a 10” flour tortilla.

Dinner Salad

$9.99

Large. Lettuce, tomato, onions, and croutons.

Taco Salad

$13.99

Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce.

Antipasto Salad

$17.99

Lettuce, tomato, onions, croutons, cheese, ham, turkey, salami, green and black olives, and pepperoni.

Tacos

Tacos: come with lettuce, tomato, taco sauce, and cheese on a 10” flour tortilla.

Beef Taco

$6.99

Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce.

Chicken Finger Taco

$7.99

Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce.

Chicken Taco

$6.99

Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce.

Fish Tacos

$8.99

Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, taco sauce, and tartar sauce.

Steak Tacos

$7.99

Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce.

Sandwiches

All served with fries.

Hamburger

$13.99

XX-large. Comes with lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, mustard, ketchup, and a pickle on the side, and a side of fries.

Fried Bologna Sandwich

$12.99

Comes with mayo, fried onions, and a side of fries.

Cheeseburger

$14.99

XX-large. Comes with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, mustard, ketchup, and a pickle on the side, and a side of fries.

Roast Beef on Weck Sandwich

$12.99

Includes horseradish and a side of fries.

Fish Fry Every Day

Fish Fry

$16.99

Comes with fries, coleslaw, mac salad, rye bread, and lemon.

Fish Sandwich

$13.99

Comes with mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, a side of tartar sauce and hot sauce, plus fries and cheese.

Shrimp Dinner

$15.99

10 pieces. Comes with fries, coleslaw, mac salad, rye bread, and lemon.

Shrimp with Fries

$13.99

Comes with 8 jumbo shrimp, fries, and cocktail sauce.

Fish & Shrimp Dinner

$17.99

1/2 fish and 1/2 shrimp. Comes with fries, mac salad, coleslaw, rye bread, and lemon.

Desserts

Chocolate Cake

$5.50

Blue Velvet Cookie Monster

$10.00

Cheesecake

$5.50

Banana Pudding Cake

$10.00

Carrot Cake

$5.50

Peach Cobbler Cheesecake

$10.00

Fried Dough

$9.99

Strawberry Crunch Cake

$10.00

Seafood

Thu-Sun

Loaded Charbroiled Oysters

$25.99+

Loaded with lump crab, spinach, Parmesan cheese, and special butter.

Steamed Clams

$12.99+

Steamed middle neck clams with special sauce.

Charbroiled Blue Crab

$15.99

Trio. Blue crab marinated in homemade special seafood sauce

Special Seafood Sauce

$1.99

Homemade seafood sauce

Buffalo

Menu

Catering

Reservations

The Patio

Late Night

Our Story

Gift Cards

We're Hiring

Terms of serviceAccessibility

Papa J's Pizza LLC 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner